Rent The Runway Vs Nuuly Formal Dresses: Rent the Runway vs. Nuuly: Which Rental Service Wins for Formal Dresses?

Rent The Runway Vs Nuuly Formal Dresses: Rent the Runway vs. Nuuly: Which Rental Service Wins for Formal Dresses?

For a formal event — wedding, gala, charity dinner — you want a dress that turns heads. But dropping $400 on a designer gown you wear once? That’s dumb. So you’re looking at rental services. Two names dominate: Rent the Runway and Nuuly.

Here’s the short answer: Rent the Runway wins for formal events. Their selection of high-end designer gowns, reliable backup sizes, and expedited shipping options make them the safer bet for black-tie occasions. Nuuly is better for everyday fashion and casual parties. But the details matter. Here’s exactly why.

How the Two Services Actually Compare for Formal Dresses

Let’s get the numbers on the table. This is what you need to know before you click “add to cart.”

Feature Rent the Runway Nuuly
Monthly subscription price $94 (4 items) + $25 for expedited shipping $98 (6 items)
One-time rental available? Yes — from $30 to $200+ per dress No — subscription only
Designer labels for formal wear Badgley Mischka, Marchesa, Sachin & Babi, Theia Anthropologie, Farm Rio, Free People — fewer formal options
Backup size option Yes — you can reserve a second size for $10 No
Shipping speed Standard 2-day; overnight available for $15 extra Standard 5–7 business days
Cleaning included? Yes Yes

The subscription price difference is small. But Nuuly’s lack of one-time rentals and slower shipping make it a gamble for a specific date. Rent the Runway lets you pay for a single dress and get it fast.

Why Rent the Runway Is Better for Black-Tie Events

Woman browsing clothing rack in boutique, exploring elegant styles.

Rent the Runway has been in the formal rental game since 2009. They know what works for a wedding guest or gala attendee. Their formal collection includes brands like Badgley Mischka (beaded gowns around $150 rental), Marchesa Notte (flowing silhouettes), and Theia (structured cocktail dresses). These are labels you actually see on red carpets.

Nuuly launched in 2019 as an Urban Outfitters subsidiary. Their inventory leans heavily on Anthropologie, Free People, and Farm Rio. Great for a brunch or a garden party. For a formal wedding with a black-tie dress code? You’ll struggle to find floor-length gowns with beading or lace. The formal section is thin.

The Backup Size Feature Is a Lifesaver

Nothing ruins a formal night like a dress that doesn’t zip. Rent the Runway lets you add a backup size for $10 per item. You get two sizes of the same dress shipped together. Return the one that doesn’t fit. Nuuly doesn’t offer this. If the dress is too tight or too loose, you’re stuck.

For a one-time wedding where you can’t swap dresses the next day, that backup option is worth the $10. Period.

Shipping Speed Matters When You Procrastinate

Rent the Runway offers standard 2-day shipping. If you need it faster, overnight is $15 extra. Their return window is flexible — you can keep the dress for 4 or 8 days depending on the plan. Nuuly ships in 5–7 business days. If your event is next Friday, you’re cutting it close. Rent the Runway gives you breathing room.

When Nuuly Actually Makes More Sense

Nuuly isn’t bad. It’s just not built for formal. But for certain situations, it’s the better choice.

If you need a cocktail dress for a semi-formal event — think a holiday party or a nice dinner — Nuuly’s $98 for 6 items gives you more variety. You can grab a slip dress from Maeve, a blazer from Pilcro, and some jewelry. For the same price as Rent the Runway’s 4 items, you get 6 pieces. That’s a better deal for a whole outfit.

Nuuly also has a better selection of plus sizes. Rent the Runway goes up to size 22 in some styles, but Nuuly carries more extended sizes in their core brands. If you wear a 3X or 4X, Nuuly’s Anthropologie collection has more options that actually fit well.

Common Mistake: Renting a Nuuly Dress for a Wedding

I’ve seen people book Nuuly for a black-tie wedding and end up with a midi dress that reads “casual Friday.” Nuuly labels things “formal” that are really just “nice.” A lace-trimmed top from Farm Rio is not a gown. Check the fabric and length before you commit. If the dress code says “floor-length,” go with Rent the Runway.

What Goes Wrong with Rental Dresses — and How to Avoid It

Side view of anonymous ethnic woman in trendy outfit choosing clothes in light bedroom at home with blue blouse on hanger in hands

Rental dresses have three common failure points. Here’s how to dodge each one.

1. The dress arrives wrinkled or damaged. Both services dry-clean after every rental. But wear and tear happens. Rent the Runway has a quality check team. If a dress arrives with a stain or tear, their customer service typically refunds or overnight ships a replacement. Nuuly’s process is slower — you’ll likely get a credit, not a replacement in time.

2. Sizing is inconsistent. A size 6 from one designer fits differently than a size 6 from another. Rent the Runway posts customer reviews with height, weight, and fit notes. Read them. Nuuly has fewer reviews per item, so you’re guessing more. Always order the backup size from Rent the Runway if you’re unsure.

3. The dress looks worse in person. Photos on both sites are styled with good lighting and models. Look for customer photos in the reviews. Rent the Runway shows real customer images. Nuuly doesn’t always. That’s a red flag.

One-Time Rental vs. Subscription: Which Should You Choose?

If you only need one dress for one event, do not subscribe. Rent the Runway’s one-time rental lets you pick a single gown, pay $30–$200, and return it after 4 days. No monthly commitment. No wasted items.

Nuuly forces you into a $98 monthly subscription. You get 6 items, but you’re paying for 5 items you don’t need. That’s $98 for one dress. Rent the Runway’s one-time rental for a Marchesa gown might be $120. You pay more for the dress itself, but you’re not paying for extras you won’t use.

If you attend multiple formal events per month? Then the $94 Rent the Runway subscription makes sense. You can rotate dresses, accessories, and even handbags. For a single event, pay per dress.

Alternatives When Neither Service Works

Two women shopping outdoors, wearing face masks for safety in bright daylight.

Sometimes neither Rent the Runway nor Nuuly fits the bill. Here’s what else exists.

The RealReal sells pre-owned designer gowns. You can buy a $1,200 Badgley Mischka for $250 and keep it forever. Good if you want to own the dress or plan to resell it. No rental timeline pressure.

Vivrelle focuses on designer handbags and jewelry but also rents gowns from The Row and Oscar de la Renta. Membership starts at $99/month. Smaller selection but higher-end.

Local bridal or formal wear shops often rent gowns for a fraction of retail. You can try it on in person. No shipping risk. Check shops near you for prom or bridesmaid dress rentals.

When to skip rental entirely: If you’re between standard sizes (e.g., a size 8 that’s tall with a long torso), rental dresses rarely fit well off the rack. Alterations aren’t possible on a rental. Buy a dress you can hem or take in.

The Verdict: Pick Rent the Runway for Formal, Nuuly for Everything Else

If you have a black-tie wedding, a gala, or any event where the dress code says “formal” or “white tie,” choose Rent the Runway. Their designer selection is stronger. The backup size option removes risk. Shipping is fast. One-time rentals exist.

If you’re dressing for a semi-formal event, a vacation dinner, or just want a wardrobe refresh for the month, Nuuly gives you more items for a similar price. Just don’t expect floor-length gowns or red-carpet labels.

One last thing: book early. Formal dresses book out weeks in advance on both platforms, especially during wedding season (May–October). Don’t wait until the week before.

Related Posts